News from ISA

13

Concerns Over ISA's 2022-2023 Election Slate

Dear Colleagues,

Over the past week, we have received numerous notes of concern about the list of at-large nominations on the current ISA nominating slate. We are quite gratified that our membership is so strongly interested in promoting diverse leadership and in cultivating that culture within ISA. We share that value strongly.

In the context of the present slate, though, we must point out the following facts about the slate and the nominating process:

  1. The Nominating Committee did a great deal of outreach to a wide range of constituencies to solicit nominations. The committee, a diverse group in itself (https://www.isanet.org/ISA/Governance/Committees/Nominating/Members), was quite diligent in this regard.  They did this work personally as well as through the mass methods coordinated through ISA HQ, including email, social media, and newsletter (all repeated times).
  2. After all that work is done, the committee is dependent on actually receiving nominations from our members. The committee does not nominate people themselves as that would entail a violation of ISA conflict of interest rules. Thus, if ISA members do not nominate a diverse group or anyone at all for that matter, the committee must move ahead with the nominees they have. Moreover, the committee is charged with a timeline for reporting laid out in the ISA Constitution.
  3. There is no constitutional mechanism for the ISA leadership or ISA HQ to reject the slate as proposed. That would far overstep our authority and would be extraordinarily bad precedent.
  4. At the deadline this summer, already later than normal to accommodate the pandemic’s impact on time and attention, the committee had only received 3 at-large nominations (at least 5 are required by current Constitution) and they wisely extended the deadline for at-large nominations. They received three more during that extended period and forwarded all 6.
  5. By current constitution, “all of the nominees for at-large representative must be from outside the recognized regions of the Association.” You may note that ISA launched a Latin American-Caribbean region and an Asia-Pacific region in recent years. That means in reality that at-large nominees can only be drawn from Europe, Middle East and Africa. Because of the geographical distribution of our membership, that heavily favors nominees from Europe because of the large membership numbers there.
  6. The constitutional revisions underway present a new way of doing at-large nominations focusing on members from “institutions in countries that are or have historically been underrepresented in the Association membership or leadership.” This will hopefully provide a broader pool for nominations moving forward.
  7. Those concerned about the slate might also wish to note that the President and VP nominations this year do not include a single white male candidate. That fact is indeed rare in the history of ISA nominated slates and the committee should be congratulated for their work in this regard.

We would be happy to discuss this further and we encourage everyone to vote before the December 5th deadline.

Sincerely,

Helen Milner, ISA President
Cameron Thies, ISA Past-President
Kristian Gleditsch, ISA President-Elect
Mark A. Boyer, ISA Executive Director

Posted in: Headquarters

Comments

There are currently no comments, be the first to post one.
Start the Discussion...
Only registered users may post comments.

        

ISA on Twitter

Search

Newsletter Archive

Check out our newsletter archives here!

Archive

April 2021 (2)
March 2021 (2)
February 2021 (4)
January 2021 (6)
December 2020 (7)
November 2020 (3)
October 2020 (2)
September 2020 (4)
August 2020 (6)
July 2020 (5)
June 2020 (4)
May 2020 (11)
April 2020 (3)
March 2020 (9)
February 2020 (8)
January 2020 (4)
December 2019 (2)
November 2019 (3)
October 2019 (5)
September 2019 (6)
August 2019 (4)
July 2019 (3)
June 2019 (4)
May 2019 (11)
April 2019 (14)
March 2019 (7)
February 2019 (4)
January 2019 (5)
December 2018 (7)
November 2018 (2)
October 2018 (8)
September 2018 (8)
August 2018 (11)
July 2018 (8)
June 2018 (9)
May 2018 (10)
April 2018 (4)
March 2018 (1)
February 2018 (6)
January 2018 (1)
December 2017 (6)
November 2017 (1)
October 2017 (2)
September 2017 (11)
August 2017 (7)
July 2017 (10)
June 2017 (15)
May 2017 (13)
April 2017 (12)
March 2017 (8)
February 2017 (20)
January 2017 (9)
December 2016 (6)
November 2016 (8)
October 2016 (10)
September 2016 (19)
August 2016 (11)
July 2016 (14)
June 2016 (14)
May 2016 (19)
April 2016 (19)
March 2016 (11)
February 2016 (5)
January 2016 (11)
December 2015 (14)
November 2015 (8)
October 2015 (4)
September 2015 (15)
August 2015 (11)
July 2015 (16)
June 2015 (8)
May 2015 (15)
April 2015 (19)
March 2015 (14)
February 2015 (7)
January 2015 (9)
December 2014 (10)
November 2014 (4)
October 2014 (14)
September 2014 (12)
August 2014 (13)
July 2014 (8)
June 2014 (6)
May 2014 (16)
April 2014 (17)
March 2014 (8)
February 2014 (15)
January 2014 (9)
December 2013 (12)
November 2013 (9)
October 2013 (20)
September 2013 (24)
August 2013 (13)
July 2013 (8)
June 2013 (11)
May 2013 (5)
April 2013 (11)
March 2013 (3)
January 2013 (1)